Order Custom Cookies
Beautiful Custom Cookies That Taste as Amazing as They Look
At Sprinkles by Stacey, I believe cookies should taste just as incredible as they look. As a trained chef, I focus on exceptional flavor and high-quality ingredients—using only the best, including King Arthur Flour, organic pure cane sugar, free-range eggs, and Nielsen-Massey vanilla bean.
My custom cookies are thoughtfully designed to be both beautiful and delicious, with gluten-free and vegan options available so everyone can enjoy a sweet treat.
As part of my commitment to quality and care, I’ve transitioned from artificial colors to plant-based colors made from nature’s own ingredients.
Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, wedding, baby shower, corporate event, or special milestone, I’d love to create something sweet and meaningful for you.
Before You Order
- 📍Pickup is in Haverhill, MA
- 🚗 Delivery is not included and is available for an additional fee based on location and availability
- 📅 Orders are not reserved until invoice is paid and contract is signed
- Custom decorated cookies range from $7.50–$10.50 each depending on design and detail
- Most designs fall between $7.50–$8.50 per cookie
- Specialty details such as metallic accents may increase pricing
Why Choose Sprinkles by Stacey
• Trained chef focused on exceptional flavor
• Premium ingredients like King Arthur Flour & Nielsen-Massey Vanilla
• Plant-based colors made from natural ingredients
• Gluten-free and vegan options available
Custom Sugar Cookie Options & Pricing
Cookie Pricing
• Custom decorated cookies range from $7.50–$10.50 each, depending on size, level of detail, and design elements
• Most designs fall between $7.50–$8.50 per cookie
• Specialty details such as metallic accents may increase pricing
Order Minimums
• Full-size cookies: 2 dozen minimum (may be split between two flavors)
• Mini cookies: 3 dozen minimum (all minis must be the same flavor)
No Artificial Colors
I’m proud to use plant-based colors made from nature’s ingredients, replacing traditional artificial food dyes.
Budget-Friendly Options
To help fit your budget, we can mix highly detailed cookies with simpler designs while still maintaining your theme.
Printed Cookies
Custom designs can be printed directly onto cookies for a crisp, professional finish—perfect for logos, photos, and detailed artwork.
Sprinkles by Stacey uses FDA-approved edible inks and also offers edible image cookies.
Dietary Options
• Vegan cookies available
• Gluten-free cookies available for an additional charge
Packaging
Each cookie comes individually packaged, labeled, and heat-sealed to ensure freshness and a beautiful presentation.
Shipping & Delivery
Per Massachusetts state law, cookies are available for local pick-up in Haverhill, MA or delivery only. Pickup details will be provided after your order is placed.
Local delivery may be available for an additional fee and is subject to availability.
Pricing Notes
Prices may change due to fluctuations in ingredient costs (such as butter, eggs, chocolate, vanilla, flour, and gluten-free ingredients, etc).
Rush orders may incur an additional fee.
Custom Sugar Cookie Flavors
A rotating selection of soft, melt-in-your-mouth sugar cookies made with premium ingredients.
Signature Flavors (included)
Signature Buttery Vanilla Bean
Soft, buttery sugar cookie infused with rich vanilla flavor.
French Toast
Maple, vanilla, cinnamon, and hazelnut in a warm, cozy cookie.
Brown Sugar Cinnamon
Rich brown sugar sweetness paired with warm cinnamon spice.
Hazelnut Churro
Inspired by the classic churro with hazelnut and cinnamon sugar.
Lemon Spritz
Fresh lemon zest folded into a bright, melt-in-your-mouth cookie.
Premium Flavors (additional charge)
Hot Cocoa Crème (new flavor)
Classic hot cocoa flavor in a soft, melt-in-your-mouth sugar cookie.
Campfire S’mores
Toasted marshmallow, chocolate, and graham cracker flavors in one indulgent cookie.
Caramel Macchiato Crème
Espresso, white chocolate, and caramel blended into a smooth, luxurious cookie.
White Chocolate Blueberry Crème
Sweet blueberries paired with creamy white chocolate.
Raspberry Crème
Tart raspberries balanced with velvety white chocolate.
Strawberries & Crème
Sweet strawberries blended with rich white chocolate.
Raspberry Zest
Raspberries brightened with orange, lemon, and lime.
Birthday Cake
Soft sugar cookie with rich vanilla buttercream flavor and dye-free colorful confetti.
Cookies & Cream
Chocolate cookie crumbs folded into creamy vanilla sugar cookie dough.
Confetti Crème
Birthday cake meets cookies & cream in a dreamy celebration flavor.
Classic Chocolate Chip
The classic chocolate chip cookie reimagined as a soft sugar cookie.
Triple Chocolate Crème
Black cocoa, Dutch cocoa, and semisweet chocolate in a rich chocolate cookie.
Almond Bliss
Almond flour and almond extract for delicate nuttiness and melt-in-your-mouth elegance.
The Booking Process
1. Submit Your Inquiry
Fill out the inquiry form below with your event details.
2. Review & Inspiration
I will review your inquiry within 1–2 business days. I’ll ask for inspiration—anything except cookie photos. I work best with invitations, color palettes, cake designs, and event décor.
Please note: I do not reproduce copyrighted characters or other bakers’ cookie designs.
3. Design Selection
Based on your inspiration, I will create a list of cookie design options with pricing for you to review and choose from.
4. Booking Your Order
Once you’ve selected your designs, I will send an invoice and cookie contract. Your order is officially booked once the invoice is paid and the contract is signed.
5. Pickup or Delivery
Per Massachusetts state law, cookies are available for pickup in Haverhill, MA. Delivery may be available for an additional fee and is subject to availability. Pickup details will be provided after your order is placed.
Quick FAQs
Have more questions? Visit the full FAQ page.
Start Your Custom Cookie Order
Fill out the inquiry form below with your event details, and I’ll get back to you within 1–2 business days to discuss design options and availability.
Submitting this form does not guarantee your event date, but I will do my best to accommodate your request.